Wilmington might be best known for its beaches and coastal charm, but locals know the city’s pizza scene is just as irresistible. From classic New York–style slices to wood-fired artisan pies, the Port City offers something for every pizza lover. Whether you’re grabbing a quick lunch, feeding the family, or pairing your pie with a local brew, here are some of our top picks for pizza perfection.

Benny’s Big Time Pizzeria
James Beard Award–winning chef Vivian Howard brings Southern soul to Italian tradition at this South Front District favorite. Expect wood-fired pizzas with perfectly blistered crusts, creative toppings, and an atmosphere that’s equal parts casual and classy.

Cugino Forno
This authentic Italian gem in the Soda Pop District fires up Neapolitan-style pies with imported ingredients and a true respect for the craft. The margherita is as traditional as it gets—simple, balanced, and unforgettable.

Slice of Life Pizzeria & Pub
A local institution with multiple locations, Slice of Life is where Wilmington’s pizza cravings meet a laid-back coastal vibe. With generous portions, great beer, and friendly service, it’s the perfect post-beach stop or casual night out.

Mellow Mushroom
A funky, family-friendly classic with creative pies, stone-baked crusts, and a fun, art-filled atmosphere. Mellow Mushroom’s downtown location pairs perfectly with an afternoon stroll along the Riverwalk.

Cousins Coal Fired Pizzeria
Using time-honored traditions, high-heat coal ovens, and recipes passed down through generations, Cousins isn’t your average pizzeria, they serve up a family legacy hot and fresh, every time.

Pizzeria Don Luca
Locally owned and operated, this downtown gem offers hand stretched dough with the freshest ingredients and traditional recipes. Check out their baked wings too!

Brooklyn Pizza Co.
With two locations, this long-standing Wilmington staple serves up traditional pies with an old-school Italian flair. Generous toppings, gooey cheese, and plenty of local love make it a must-visit for pizza purists.

Tarantelli’s
While best known for its upscale Italian dining, Tarantelli’s wood-fired pizzas are a hidden gem—thin, crisp, and topped with fresh local ingredients. Perfect for date night or a special evening downtown.

Top 3 Must-Try Pizzas in Wilmington

If you can only visit a few spots, these stand out as local legends:

At The Bluffs on the Cape Fear, we love celebrating everything that makes Wilmington delicious. From world-class seafood to the city’s best burgers and pizza, there’s always something fresh to discover. When you live just minutes away, every meal can feel like a vacation—because paradise is always on the menu.

We invite you to explore the Wilmington lifestyle by visiting our unique riverside community, where you can purchase your dream home. Stay up-to-date on the latest happenings in The Bluffs by tuning into our Facebook page!